Should You Have Your Gutters Replaced When Replacing Your Roof?

When it comes to protecting your home from North Carolina’s unpredictable weather, Summit Roofing of NC is the trustworthy team you can count on. Our skilled roofers bring years of experience installing and repairing asphalt shingles, flat roofing, metal roofing, and more; all with an eye for detail and a commitment to quality. Alongside roofing, we also provide tailored gutter solutions, including seamless options and multiple gutter styles designed to move water efficiently and safeguard your foundation. Since gutters and roofing work hand in hand, many homeowners ask us the same question: when should I replace my gutters, and does it make sense to do it when replacing the roof?

Let’s dive into why this decision matters, what factors to weigh, and how to balance roof and gutter replacement cost for long-term home protection.

North Carolina Climate and Your Gutters

Living in North Carolina means facing hot, humid summers, heavy seasonal rains, and the occasional severe storm. These conditions put constant strain on both your roof and gutters. A healthy roof channels water downward, but if your gutters aren’t doing their job, rainwater can pool around the foundation, seep into siding, or back up under shingles. Over time, this can lead to mold, leaks, and costly structural damage.

Because your roofing system and gutters work as a team, it’s worth thinking about both when scheduling major exterior upgrades. If you’re already investing in a new roof, should you also consider gutter replacement at the same time?

Should You Replace Gutters When Replacing Your Roof?

The short answer: not always, but it’s often a smart choice. Here’s why.

1. Accessibility:  When your roofing contractor is already on-site replacing shingles or installing a new roof, the gutters are easy to access. If they’re nearing the end of their lifespan, tackling gutter replacement at the same time can save you from paying extra for future labor and setup costs.
   
   
2. Matching Lifespans:  A quality roof can last 20–30 years, depending on the material. Gutters typically last 20 years for aluminum and even longer for steel or copper. If your gutters are old or showing any signs of wear, replacing them now ensures both systems age together, reducing the chance of mismatched repairs later.
   
   
3. Preventing Damage: During roof replacement, your old gutters must be detached and reattached. If they’re already weak, bent, or leaking, reattaching them could cause damage or make existing issues worse. Installing new gutters avoids this risk and guarantees your new roof and gutter system function seamlessly.
   
   
4. Upgrading Performance: North Carolina’s intense rain events demand efficient drainage. If your current gutters are undersized or poorly pitched, upgrading them during a roof replacement ensures you get a system that matches your home’s needs and your new roofline design.
   
   

When Should I Replace My Gutters?

Even if you aren’t planning a new roof, there are clear signs it’s time for gutter replacement:

• Cracks, holes, or visible rust spots
  
  
• Sagging sections pulling away from the fascia
  
  
• Water pooling near your foundation.
  
  
• Peeling paint or water stains on siding
  
  
• Frequent clogs despite regular cleaning
  
  
• Seam leaks or constant dripping
  
  

If you notice any of these issues, new gutters may be necessary, whether or not your roof is also due for replacement.

Gutter Replacement Cost Considerations

Understandably, cost is a major factor for homeowners deciding whether to replace gutters during a roof project. Gutter replacement cost varies depending on materials (aluminum, steel, copper), style (K-style or half-round), and whether you choose seamless options. In North Carolina, homeowners can expect an average range of $6–$12 per linear foot for aluminum gutters, with higher-end materials like copper costing significantly more.

While adding gutter replacement increases your upfront investment, it can ultimately save money by preventing water damage and avoiding additional labor charges down the road. Plus, you’ll enjoy peace of mind knowing your entire exterior drainage system was installed together by the same trusted team.

Why Summit Roofing of NC?

At Summit Roofing of NC, we understand that your home is more than just a building; it’s your family’s safe haven. That’s why we offer not only dependable roofing services but also professional gutter solutions that fit your budget and your home’s unique design. We never push unnecessary upgrades, but we’ll always be transparent about whether gutter replacement makes sense alongside a roof replacement.

Our services include:

• Emergency roofing repairs
  
  
• Asphalt shingle roofing
  
  
• Flat roofing systems
  
  
• Durable metal roofing
  
  
• Gutter installation (K-style, half-round, seamless, and more)
  
  

With our experienced team, you’ll get honest recommendations, quality materials, and craftsmanship built to handle North Carolina’s climate for years to come.

Final Thoughts

So, should you replace gutters when replacing your roof? While it’s not always necessary, it’s often a wise investment, especially if your gutters are aging, damaged, or undersized for our heavy rainfall. Considering when to replace my gutters as part of your roof upgrade can save money in the long run, streamline the project, and make sure that your home is fully protected from the elements. For more information, check out our blog about the year-round roofing & gutter calendar for NC homeowners.

Call Us Today!

Ready to find out if gutter replacement is the right move for your home? Contact Summit Roofing of NC today for a free, no-obligation inspection. Our friendly experts will evaluate your roof and gutters together, explain your options clearly, and help you choose the best path forward. With Summit Roofing, you can rest easy knowing your home is covered, top to bottom.